Quote:
Originally Posted by jacobcartmill
Zach,
I've had this discussion with a few friends before with their projects when they become frustrated; while i appreciate a good "venting" (and I legitimately feel for you in this situation) you have to present this in a realistic way, and not simply blame "EFI" as if the problems are inherent.
|
Yes, you are correct. . It's not an inherent problem for "EFI". .
Quote:
Originally Posted by jacobcartmill
here is my understanding of the project:
1. (complexity) you ordered a very custom harness for a unique project, including a milspec firewall connector, a custom fuse box, aftermarket injectors on an aftermarket carb-style intake manifold, an aftermarket crank trigger, a custom LS1 coil-on-plug setup, and a not-widely-used rotary ECU (most haltech people use the platinum series, and now the elite series) that has a different ECU connector than most others.
|
-Custom harness: Yes but what is "very" custom? How is it any different for anything else? Our cars aren't cookie cutter cars, so all these custom harnesses will be tailored to one's application. .
-Connector: What complication does this pose other than expense and work for the builder?
-Fuse box: Is this not standard equipment? If not, why?
-Everything else mentioned: All other items mentioned are basic components for any EFI system to operate. . Sure some components may be "different" but they still serve the same purpose. Also, the injectors are common Bosch injectors mounted in the center iron, not on the TB like some. As for the ECU, what does not-widely-used have to do with "
(complexity)" considering I searched for a computer that best suited my needs, seems stupid-simple to me. . . Is it that the software is different? Is it that it's harder to tune?
Quote:
Originally Posted by jacobcartmill
2. (more complexity) this work was all done via mail order, which adds even more risk -- likelihood of things not working correctly. many small things can be left out of phone conversations and email - errors or things that may be easily caught if the car is right in front of the person building the harness.
|
I can't say anything about this except that I completely agree! ! I/We found and corrected a couple issues and I still had to return the harness for that trigger wheel sensor issue.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jacobcartmill
3. (more complexity as a result of complexity) your setup is so far from stock that you can't simply load a decent base map and drive the car, so even more tuning is required than usual. you have me and pauly available to help with this portion (as we both), and as I recall, we got things running quite well in many situations: full throttle at 12:1 AFR, cold start (minus the custom BAC valve and setup that we couldn't figure out) hot start, idle, cruising, ~2% o2 control activated (in our recent tuning session) in low load and idle.
|
Yes, it's not stock and far from it but again, is it really that different from anything else that you're starting from scratch with? Yes it's unfortunate there aren't a million other individuals with the same set-up as mine to copy/paste a MAP but you guys seemed to do well with nothing to start with. I appreciate all the help from you guys! Without help from individuals like yourself who have experience with this stuff as well as an understanding of how it all works, I wouldn't know where to start. . Throwing a laptop at me and telling me to figure it out doesn't work, I need guidance and supervision especially with something I'm not comfortable with in the first place. So again, Thank you!
Quote:
Originally Posted by jacobcartmill
4. I recall you being very happy with the setup and tuning prior to the harness/ground issue popping up. was this not the case?
|
Yes, I'm happy when things work
Quote:
Originally Posted by jacobcartmill
big picture:
this is your first EFI project, and frankly, it could not be more complex.
furthermore, why did you go EFI in the first place? what drew you to it? was your carburetor working correctly and tuned nicely to run in all situations the car sees? if so, why not put a carb back on the car?
|
-I went EFI to do something different. . but still wanting to stay 'true to my roots' and keep the bay tidy and simple is why I chose the components I did. This took years of research.
-I was drawn to EFI around the time FAST, Holley, MSD and others came out with the self learning bolt on kits. Many phone calls and time spent with tech support discouraged me for years after (these kits wont work for various reasons) but there was still part of me that wanted to pursue this new uncharted territory. . .
-(*see note) Until the year or so before removing the carb stuff, the car ran great! I know that's hard for you to believe being that you're one of those EFI Elitist
but it really ran great! It was neck and neck with Robs turbo 7 at DGRR one year, it was neck and neck with a 398hp EVO in an 1/8th mile, and it was simple! Dead-nuts-simple! If it broke, I could have it going in no time at all. Something happens now and I'm F'ed because I'm too dependent on others especially if its a harness issue.
-Put the stuff back on? ? You know, I seriously considered this thought many times! I mean really considered it, there's part of me that misses the simpler times where I could just get in, turn the key, and go. . But this simply can not happen as I have sold every single component from the old set-up.
*and even if I still had all the necessary components to go back to carb (aside from the fact that I'm in too deep giggity), I wouldn't because the performance started degrading. . was it the carb? I don't know but it got to the point that I had to do something because I couldn't enjoy the car on any of our trips without some carb related issue. It was at B3R ~2013/4 that was the last straw that helped push me into the EFI world when I had one carb issue after the other.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jacobcartmill
ultimately, you can't blame EFI for this. you have to blame the situation and the complexity of this project. you ordered a very custom mail order harness, and it had a couple errors (one of which apparently killed the ECU)
|
No, I'm just upset about all the issues I've dealt with along the way! All were mistakes that should have never happened but they did and I'm saltier than the Dead Sea because of it but I'm somewhat over it and just want to get this POS running. And again. . . a custom harness is a custom harness, what makes mine with the bare minimums (minus the bulkhead connector) any more complex than a REW harness? ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by jacobcartmill
you didn't simply "go efi," which I would consider installing a stock T2 longblock and haltech into your car.
you went "very complex custom EFI harness via mail order to mate several different custom parts together" and you're seeing the product of the multiplied risk biting you in the ass.
|
And again. . blah blah blah. . no different than. . . 3rd gen, all-out-kustom, tricked-out-yo. . harness! That most importantly. . was built by a professional that does this sort of stuff for a living. But you are correct in biting me in the ass!
Quote:
Originally Posted by jacobcartmill
I broke this down for JohnnyK recently with his "the most difficult custom FD project possible" when he was discouraged. he made a couple changes, got back on track, and now it's working out great. now you go do the same: bug the piss out of Ludwig, have some conversations with him and stay on him to fix the harness issue and replace the ECU, get the harness back, and the project is basically done, correct?
|
Yes, but I absolutely hate "bugging the piss out of" anyone to get things done. . that and I want it done right without rushing it so I'm giving him his space but within reason. . I'll call next week since I haven't heard from him at all this week and get more details on everything.