I didn't read the whole thread, but just wanted to add some of my experiences. Use the information however you want, it's here for you.
255/40/17 on 17x9 +24

-You will need a coilover type suspension since OE style coils will interfere.
-If you have sloppy wheel bearings, the wheel will most likely rub on the coils.
-I was running -2deg F -1R on the street, with rolled fenders. The car was also my DD so tire wear was adversely affected (especially during my new motor's break-in)
I wanted to run a more DD friendly camber setting, so I ended up flaring the fronts and rears a little bit, it's not really noticeable.
I have since moved to a different car, running a different set of wheels.
17x9 +17, 255/40/17
The Mandeville BBK gives me a 3mm thinner rotor hat up front, so the wheel is essentially +20mm. To use 255's up front with tire friendly camber settings, I had to really flare out the fender - about an inch. I did an okay job - it could be done better but it suits my purposes for now.
The rears got the same roll and flare, and was considerably easier to do than the fronts.
The alignment I run on the street is very mild - -0.5deg F -1deg R
Autocross: -3deg F -1deg R, 1/16th toe out F, 0 rear, OE caster
Road course: Similar, but 0 toe F and R, and -2deg F (Really doesn't hold much weight since I auto-x more)
Pics:
Hope this helps!